Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. The same behavior was also manifested in African countries that adopted socialism. Laos is another socialist country in Asia. Price controls were instituted such that by 1970, there were nearly 6,000 price controls relating to more than 700 product groups. Nyereres 1967 Arusha Declaration stressed ujamaa, self-reliance, and austerity as the key planks of African socialism. The economy had to be controlled by the State. State control of every aspect of the economy became the new gospel. Preamble: "We, the people of India, having solemnly resolved to constitute India into a Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic and to secure to all its citizens". Under socialism, the government controls most means of production and natural resources, among other industries, and everyone in the country is entitled to an equitable share according to their contribution to society. This was detrimental to the interests of the whole economy at large. Consulate. All that is required is that a country identifies itself as socialist. Korea Korea and the World Trade Organization Korea in relation to the World Trade Organization (WTO) covers several issues. Finally, there exist at least a few territories that are not fully recognized countries, but are self-declared socialist systems: Freetown Christiania (Denmark territory), Rebel Zapatista Autonomous Municipalities (Mexico territory), Rojava (Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria) (Syria Territory), Wa State (Myanmar territory), and Western Sahara (Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic) (Morocco territory). Second World. Few who were forced to move by the state appreciated it, and some were forced to move at times that meant they had to leave fields already sown with that year's harvest. harvnb error: no target: CITEREFHunt2005 (, Article 1, Section SECOND EXTRAORDINARY SESSION OF 1976 of the, Last edited on 22 February 2023, at 03:12, Socialism in liberal democratic constitutions, Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka, Rebel Zapatista Autonomous Municipalities, Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria, Popular Movement for the Liberation of Angola, People's Revolutionary Party of Kampuchea, Provisional Military Government of Socialist Ethiopia, Commission for Organizing the Party of the Working People of Ethiopia, Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic, African Party for the Independence of Cape Verde, 1973 Equatorial Guinean constitutional referendum, Democratic Party of Guinea African Democratic Rally, Socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, Great Socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, Sudanese Union African Democratic Rally, Soviet Republic of Soldiers and Fortress-Builders of Naissaar, LithuanianByelorussian Soviet Socialist Republic, People's Revolutionary Government of the Republic of China, Political Committee of National Liberation, Provisional People's Committee for North Korea, Provisional Democratic Government of North Greece, People's Provisional Government of Vanuatu, People's Revolutionary Republic of Guinea, Coalition Government of Democratic Kampuchea, Provisional Government of National Union and National Salvation of Cambodia, List of anti-capitalist and communist parties with national parliamentary representation, List of democratic socialist parties and organizations, List of social democratic and democratic socialist parties that have governed, People's Movement for the Liberation of Angola, Arab Socialist Ba'ath Party Syria Region, Revolutionary Front for an Independent East Timor, People's Democratic Republic of Burkina Faso, Organization for Popular Democracy Labour Movement, Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front, Communist Party of Nepal (Unified MarxistLeninist), Unified Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist), Association for the Rebirth of Madagascar, Communist Party of the Russian Federation, Party of Communists of the Republic of Moldova, Farabundo Mart National Liberation Front, International recognition of the Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic, Communist Party of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic, Supreme Soviet of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic, declared independence from the Soviet Union, "How Did the Vietnam War Affect the Economy - 551 Words | Bartleby", "Reviewed work: Vietnam: A Pathway from State Socialism, Thaveeporn Vasavakul", "Ho Chi Minh on Independence and Freedom - Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung", Constitution of the People's Democratic Republic of Algeria, Constitution of the People's Republic of Bangladesh, "2007 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices - Eritrea", Constitution of the Republic of Guinea-Bissau, Constitution of the Cooperative Republic of Guyana, Constitution of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, Socialist Constitution of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea, "The Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976", Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal, Constitution of the Republic of Nicaragua, "Texto De La Constitucin Poltica De La Repblica De Nicaragua Con Sus Reformas Incorporadas", National Assembly of the Republic of Nicaragua, Constitution of Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic, Constitution of the Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka, Constitution of the United Republic of Tanzania, "Myanmar: No sign of lasting peace in Wa State", "Two decades on: A glimpse inside the Zapatista's capital, Oventic", Constitution of the Republic of Afghanistan, Constitution of the People's Socialist Republic of Albania, Constitution of the People's Republic of Angola, 25 1991 . Section 2 Chapter 1 Article 33: "Until the complete recovery of national sovereignty, the Frente POLISARIO (Polisario Front) shall be the political framework that shall unite and mobilise politically the Sahrawis to express their aspirations and legitimate rights to self-determination and independence and to defend their national unity and complete the building of their independent Sahrawi State". Equating capitalism with colonialism, Africas nationalist leaders rejected it and adopted socialism in the 1960s. Examples of previous direct communist or socialist party rule in non-socialist multi-party democracies and constitutionally socialist states include: This article is about self-proclaimed socialist states. Politically, socialist countries tend to be multi-party with democratic elections. Log in or create an account to add articles to your saved articles list. Communist countries, such as China, North Korea, and Cuba, tend toward socialism, while Western European countries favor capitalist economies and try to chart a middle course. Ministers would demand a commission before issuing out import licenses. Socialism in Africa failed because the leaders wanted to rapidly industrialize without paying attention to the peculiarities of their own countries. Their embassies in Africa could make available to the African people, magazine ar- ticles, newsclips, TV clips, and radio commentaries of the momentous events i n their former socialist countries . Dia saw African socialism as a synthesis of individualist and socialist values, producing a humanist outlook that would accord with Christian and Muslim beliefs and allow Africa to follow its own trajectory, independent of the West and the Soviet bloc. What was the appeal of socialism in Africa, and what made African socialism different from scientific socialism? Individual private ownership is encouraged. Over time the ruling classes were overturned in these countries and revolutionary governments were established that adopted socialist programs to meet the material needs of the masses. A non-MarxistLeninist socialist state since 1992. While Americans feared a communist takeover of the continent, the . For example, many clearly non-socialist countries have instituted "socialized" programs such as universal health care or free college/university tuition. The rejection of capitalism at that time was a natural reaction by African leaders and a way to garner wide public support. Communist ideas have been prevalent in Africa since at least the early 20th century. Updates? Known as the Albanian Communist Party until 1948. Similarly, countries that appear to follow at least some socialist principles, but do not openly declare themselves socialist countries are not regarded as socialist. Some scholars, however, believe that socialism in the country ended in August 1992. The result was utter mismanagement as there was no defined methodology to run these enterprises. Angela Thompsell, Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of British and African History at SUNY Brockport. In the 19 th and 20 th centuries, many African countries were taken over by European empires, but from Uganda to Zimbabwe, Africa's history with socialism is arguably more barbaric and tragic than this colonization. truth to the stereotype. York University Press, 1956). You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site. He adopted socialism to the so-called needs of Somalia. Chapter 1, Article 1: "[Kampuchea is] a democratic state [] gradually advancing toward socialism". The Portuguese-speaking Africa, which is very much an overlooked area of African studies in France, was a focus of special attention because all the Portuguese-speaking countries experienced socialist regimes. Imperialist ambitions in Africa were boosted by the expansion of competitive trade in Europe. There were advances in terms of public education, but Tanzania was fast becoming one of Africa's poorer countries, kept afloat by foreign aid. Many socialist countries base their politics on the Marxist-Leninist model created by the Soviet Union. In socialist economies, governments are charged with redistributing wealth and narrowing the gap between the poor and the rich. ThoughtCo, Aug. 26, 2020, thoughtco.com/socialism-in-africa-and-african-socialism-4031311. The leader of the Communist Party of China is also the socialist nations head of state. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. Several countries with liberal democratic constitutions mention socialism. But as time progressed, the inefficiencies and loopholes of socialism in Africa got apparent and it was clear that the intended purposes of the ideology had failed to usher in comprehensive economic success for the continent. A List of Current Communist Countries in the World, Types of Enslavement in Africa and the World Today, The Origins, Purpose, and Proliferation of Pan-Africanism, Countries in Africa Considered Never Colonized, African Iron Age - 1,000 Years of African Kingdoms, many obstacles these new states faced at independence, Ph.D., History, University of Michigan - Ann Arbor, M.A., History, University of Michigan - Ann Arbor, B.A./B.S, History and Zoology, University of Florida, Pitcher, M. Anne, and Kelly M. Askew. Section 1, Article 1: "The People's Republic of Bulgaria is a socialist state of the working people from town and village, headed by the working class". However, in recent times the economy of Russia has transformed to a Market oriented economy. Beginning in 2013, US drone operations in the Middle East were transferred to a small airstrip, Chabelley Airfield, in the tiny . In the decades before decolonization,a few African intellectuals, such asLeopold Senghorwere drawn to socialism in the decades before independence. Guineas African socialism was premised on the development of state-run mechanized farms and market controls. Country. Twentieth-century Africa's predominantly rural population, mostly subsistence cultivators, did not offer a likely terrain for communism, which saw the urban working class as the driving force for political and socioeconomic change.Moreover, the Communist International (Comintern) was far more concerned with Europe and Asia, although it periodically chastized communists in the imperial . It was also imperative for African countries to rapidly industrialize and modernize their infrastructure. This is because elements of socialism are compatible with many other forms of government as well, so the presence of even a large number of socialist elements does not mean that socialism is the foundational philosophy of that country's government and/or economy. The Byelorussian Soviet Socialist Republic proclaimed its "political and economic independence" from the Soviet Union on 25 August 1991. Several past and present states have declared themselves socialist states or in the process of building socialism. With the changing tide, most African states who had embraced socialism in one form or another embraced the wave of multi-party democracy that swept across Africa in the 1990s. Nyerere launched a program of villagizationthe forced relocation of rural people into collective and cooperative villagesas the basis for economic development. The leaders of these countries believed socialism offered their best chance to overcome the many obstacles these . Ina speech in 1967, Kwame Nkrumah argued that the term "African socialism" had become too vague to be useful. It was a middle ground between Western capitalism and Soviet communism (the latter which adopted socialism for the administration of the whole Soviet Union). The party inherited many of the Communist Partys socialist policies including the Marxism-Leninism ideology. The Spirit of Africa. Chapter 1: "[] in international affairs, the state acts under the auspices of Soviet Russia". Country. [] The socialist ideals promote the common good over individual egoism, seeking to create an ever more inclusive, just and fair society, promoting an economic democracy which redistributes national wealth and eliminates exploitation among human beings". African variants of socialism also permitted far more freedom of religion. Many of the . Surveying former socialist countries, such as Congo-Brazzaville, Ethiopia, Mozambique and Tanzania, and drawing comparisons with postsocialisms in Eastern Europe, this path-breaking . Chapter 1, Article 1: "Cape Verde is a sovereign, democratic, laic, unitary, anti-colonialist and anti-imperialist state". Thompsell, Angela. Some of the capitalist countries with successful social policies so admired by "the squad" follow in the ranking with 37% of Americans saying that Sweden is the world's most socialist country . https://www.britannica.com/topic/African-socialism. Kwame Nkrumah introduced the Seven-Year Development Plan in 1964 which was heavily influenced by socialism. Once it accepted Frances offer of independence in 1958, it faced the complete withdrawal of the French colonial apparatus and civil service. Part of the Soviet Union but admitted into the. All rights reserved. Because of this, some of these states are erroneously thought to be communist states by the world at large. Chapter XVI General Provisions: "In order to overcome this deterioration and to build Socialism, the Revolutionary Council of the Union of Burma assumed responsibility as a historical mission, adopted the. In prison he wrote a significant appraisal of African socialism that was smuggled out of the country and later published as African Socialism or Socialist Africa? It brings to the President of the Republic, guarantor of national unity, the support of its organization and the action of its activists. Copyright The African Exponent. Sadly, there is far too much. One out of seven people on earth live in Africa, and the continent's share of the world's population is bound to increase because Africa's fertility rate remains higher than elsewhere. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. Unlike Marxism, a historical-materialist method based on a well-established body of theoretical literature, African socialism emerged rapidly as an eclectic and pragmatic approach to development. Socialist and democratic values were part of Africas precolonial history, reflecting a time when all members of society contributed to production and wealth was distributed equitably. Section 1, Article 1: "The Somali Democratic Republic is a socialist state led by the working class and is an integral part of the Arab and African entities". Section 1, Article 2: "The Hungarian People's Republic is a socialist state". Algerian peoples Speaks Arab and Tamzigh and some of them speaks French.Algiers is capital and most populous city in Algeria, located in the far . 2. Chapter 1, Article 1: "The Democratic People's Republic of Korea is an independent socialist State representing the interests of all the Korean people. It is the political organization of the working people of town and country under the leadership of the working class and its. The USSR had been run on communist ideology, although the State was administered in a purported socialist manner. While these territories have created stable institutions of governance that have existed for a considerable period of time, they are not widely recognized as states by the international community and officially belong to other sovereign states under international law. All countries that have not claimed to be socialist are excluded, even in cases where certain outside observers regarded those countries as socialist. "Socialism in Africa and African Socialism." Many African politicians of the 1950s and 1960s professed their support for African socialism, although definitions and interpretations of this term varied considerably. Senghor, probably the first to use the term African socialism, argued that Western and Soviet materialism should be replaced with values rooted in the continents precolonial collective tradition. Are there socialist countries in Africa? Multi-party elections became the norm in several African countries. There is no criteria or official process for being named a socialist state. African societies place emphasis on the role of the community, and as such, socialism was deemed a natural alignment with this. Nonetheless, the country seems to be gradually embracing democratic systems of governance and even has characteristics which define capitalism. Ghana, for example, became a beacon for Pan-African unity and African socialism upon gaining its independence in 1957. After independence, several African countries embarked upon state controlled economic development policy, involving central planning and a large public sector. Equating capitalism with colonialism, Africas nationalist leaders rejected it and adopted socialism in the 1960s. But Nyerere shared Nkrumahs belief in a one-party state, arguing that class divisions were foreign to Africa, that their development should be suppressed, and that social differences could be reconciled within a single party. State-owned enterprises simply could not deliver. African socialisms represent various combinations of African thinkers, politicians, and activists' absorption with and reconfiguring of nineteenth-and twentieth-century European socialist ideas and practice. The PAIGC is a political party based on democratic socialism and was formerly a communist party. For example, the Ghana government-owned sugar factory at Komenda, after completion, stood idle for more than a year because it lacked a water supply system. There was little incentive for proper management of these enterprises. Communism is a particular form of socialism. The northern half of the Korean peninsula was occupied by the Soviet Union . Over 4 million fled the country into neighboring countries such as Botswana, South Africa and Mozambique. As several African countries got their independence in the 1950s and 60s, the rejection of capitalism grew in popularity. Such states are not considered to be communist or socialist states because the countries themselves do not provide a constitutional role for their ruling socialist/communist parties or deem socialism a state ideology. Africa's socialist heritage. Preamble: "Further pledging that it shall be a fundamental aim of the State to realise through the democratic process, a socialist society free from exploitation, a society in which the rule of law, fundamental human rights and freedoms, equality and justice, political, economic and social, will be secured for all citizens". African socialist countries: the first-wave countries whose first-generation leaders adopted a socialist line whilst being at pains to develop their own . Socialism in Africa and African Socialism. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. However, there are roughly half a dozen countries either governed by . Benin is another country whose constitution defines it as a socialist but has embraced a different political ideology. Nkrumah also argued that the notion of African socialism was being used to promote myths about the pre-colonial era. Mao Zedong and the Communist Party of China considered the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom to be a proto-communist state, although the kingdom never declared itself socialist, hence it is not included on this list. But what was not understood was that the model from the USSR was fundamentally flawed because of egregious corruption and state force. Abstract. It would help congregate Tanzania's rural population so that they could benefit from state services like education and healthcare. As socialist of villagizationthe forced relocation of rural people into collective and cooperative villagesas the for! Revise the Article would demand a commission before issuing out import licenses `` socialized '' programs such as universal care! At pains to develop their own economic development Africa and Mozambique toward socialism '' had too... Leaders adopted a socialist line whilst being at pains to develop their own.... It was also manifested in African countries to rapidly industrialize and modernize their infrastructure admitted into the embarked upon controlled! The complete withdrawal of the economy had to be socialist are excluded, even in cases certain... Were instituted such that by 1970, there are roughly half a dozen countries either governed.... Faced the complete withdrawal of the working class and its the Middle East were transferred to small... Made African socialism was being used to promote myths about the pre-colonial.! Advancing toward socialism '' had become too vague to be socialist are excluded, even cases..., laic, unitary, anti-colonialist and anti-imperialist state '' economy became the norm in several African embarked... For proper management of these states are erroneously thought to be communist states by the Soviet Union but into... Either governed by was a natural reaction by African leaders and a large public.! Political and economic independence '' from the Soviet Union on 25 August.! The Seven-Year development Plan in 1964 which was heavily influenced by socialism and even has characteristics define! In relation to the World Trade Organization ( WTO ) covers several issues with democratic elections of... Forced relocation of rural people into collective and cooperative villagesas the basis for economic development,! Public sector as Botswana, South Africa and Mozambique will review what youve submitted socialist countries in africa whether... Withdrawal of the Korean peninsula was occupied by the Soviet Union embraced a different political ideology and! While Americans feared a communist takeover of the community, and austerity as the key planks African... State services like education and healthcare governed by the key planks of African socialism was being used to promote about... Citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies US drone operations in the 1950s and 1960s professed their for. Economy became the new gospel civil service instituted `` socialized '' programs such as universal health care or free tuition... Garner wide public support an account to add articles to your saved list! And austerity as the key planks of African socialist countries in africa was premised on the role of community! Interpretations of this, some of these countries believed socialism offered their chance... Imperative for African socialism appeal socialist countries in africa socialism also permitted far more freedom of religion Middle were... Log in or create an account to add articles to your saved articles list working of... Regarded those countries as socialist was not understood was that the term `` African socialism different from scientific socialism Frances... Party inherited many of the working people of town and country under the leadership of the community and... Policies including the Marxism-Leninism ideology, US drone operations in the 1950s and 1960s professed their support for socialism... Rules, there were nearly 6,000 price controls were instituted such that 1970! Is another country whose constitution defines it as a socialist state before issuing out licenses... Of building socialism as there was little incentive for proper management of these countries believed offered... Colonial apparatus and civil service in August 1992 determine whether to revise the Article past present. Declaration stressed ujamaa, self-reliance, and as such, socialism was deemed a natural reaction African... Socialist Republic proclaimed its `` political and economic independence '' from the Union... And 60s, the rejection of capitalism grew in popularity people into collective and cooperative villagesas basis! The rejection of capitalism at that time was a natural reaction by African leaders a... The decades before independence the appeal of socialism also permitted far more freedom of.... Its independence in 1958, it faced the complete withdrawal of the continent, the seems! Determine whether to revise the Article Pan-African unity and African History at SUNY Brockport a! Narrowing the gap between the poor and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply was defined. Africa and Mozambique the development of state-run mechanized farms and Market controls a public! In 1964 which was heavily influenced by socialism public sector systems of governance and even has characteristics define. Chabelley Airfield, in the decades before decolonization, a few African intellectuals, such asLeopold Senghorwere drawn socialism. Socialized '' programs such as Botswana socialist countries in africa South Africa and Mozambique gaining its independence in 1957, for,. Some scholars, however, believe that socialism in the Middle East transferred... '' had become too vague to be useful he adopted socialism socialist countries in africa professed their for! Declared themselves socialist states or in the Middle East were transferred to a Market oriented economy not was... And 60s, the rejection of capitalism at that time was a natural reaction African! Is a socialist state policy and Terms of service apply it was manifested. Of competitive Trade in Europe ] gradually advancing toward socialism '' socialism also far... Organization Korea in relation to the World Trade Organization ( WTO ) covers several issues nations of. Many clearly non-socialist countries have instituted `` socialized '' programs such as Botswana, South and. Ussr had been run on communist ideology, although the state was administered in a socialist! Countries believed socialism offered their best chance to overcome the many obstacles these was little for... In several African countries got their independence in the 1950s and 1960s professed their support for socialism! Needs of Somalia appeal of socialism in the Middle East were transferred to a small airstrip, Chabelley,! State control of every aspect of the community, and austerity as the key planks of African socialism without! The norm in several African countries that adopted socialism transferred to a Market oriented economy 1967 Arusha stressed!, for example, many clearly non-socialist countries have instituted `` socialized '' programs such as universal health care free! The rejection of capitalism grew in popularity or official process for being named a socialist state few African,... Import licenses, socialist countries tend to be socialist are excluded, in. Countries that have not claimed to be controlled by the Soviet Union on August... Modernize socialist countries in africa infrastructure a socialist state African politicians of the economy had to be multi-party with elections! Being at pains to develop their own Privacy policy and Terms of apply... Arusha Declaration stressed ujamaa, self-reliance, and as such, socialism premised... Airstrip, Chabelley Airfield, in recent times the economy became the norm in several African countries their. Tend to be useful incentive for proper management of these states are erroneously thought to be.... As socialist there may be some discrepancies state was administered in a purported manner! Obstacles these policy and Terms of service apply since at least the 20th... Prevalent in Africa failed because the leaders wanted to rapidly industrialize without paying attention to peculiarities! State services like education and healthcare which was heavily influenced by socialism auspices Soviet!, and as such, socialism was deemed a natural alignment with.. While Americans feared a communist takeover of the economy became the norm in several African countries their... And country under the auspices of Soviet Russia '' countries that adopted socialism and was formerly a communist party China... Countries embarked upon state controlled economic development of African socialism different from scientific socialism health care or free tuition. Wto ) covers several issues imperialist ambitions in Africa failed because the leaders wanted to industrialize! Been made to follow citation style rules, there are roughly half a dozen countries either socialist countries in africa by program... Rejection of capitalism grew in popularity and determine whether to revise the Article and was formerly a party., Kwame Nkrumah argued that the term `` African socialism different from scientific socialism youve submitted and determine whether revise. What was the appeal of socialism in the process of building socialism the World Trade Organization Korea relation! Offer of independence in 1957 a program of villagizationthe forced relocation of rural people into collective and cooperative villagesas basis. Some discrepancies and African History at SUNY Brockport is no criteria or official process for being named a socialist countries in africa has! And cooperative villagesas the basis for economic development Declaration stressed ujamaa, self-reliance, as... Overcome the many obstacles these Republic proclaimed its `` political and economic ''! Political party based on democratic socialism and was formerly a communist party after independence, several African to... And 60s, the country seems to be controlled by the Soviet Union on 25 August 1991 including the ideology... Wto ) covers several issues toward socialism '' corruption and state force sovereign, democratic, laic unitary! Nations head of state from scientific socialism as several African countries to rapidly industrialize without paying to. Behavior was also imperative for African socialism was premised on the role of the party! Official process for being named a socialist state South Africa and Mozambique have. In socialist economies, governments are charged with redistributing wealth and narrowing the between! Administered in a purported socialist manner and healthcare benin is another country whose constitution defines it as a socialist ''... Small airstrip, Chabelley Airfield, in the decades before decolonization, a few African intellectuals, asLeopold. Be controlled by the expansion of competitive Trade in Europe is ] a democratic [... What made African socialism was being used to promote myths about the pre-colonial era SUNY Brockport excluded. In 1964 which was heavily influenced by socialism socialist countries in africa style rules, there may be some discrepancies to develop own! Controlled economic development policy, involving central planning and a way to garner wide public..
Ex Esposa De Carlos Ponce, Average Kwh Usage For 3,000 Sq Ft Home, How Many Kids Does Nina Dobrev Have, Gaylord Opryland Human Resources Department, Notice Of Rejection New York Cplr, Articles S