The federal penalties for cyberstalking are up to five years in prison without the possibility of parole at a minimum. Posting messages to online bulletin boards and discussion groups with the victims personal information, such as home address, phone number or Social Security number. And if a defendant is convicted of cyberstalking causing the death of a victim, that defendant could be sentenced to up to life in prison. 18 U.S. Code 2261A, titled stalking, makes it a federal crime for a person to "engage in a pattern of conduct that places a person in reasonable fear of bodily injury or death. (1) A person is guilty of cyber harassment if the person, with intent to harass or intimidate any other person, and under circumstances not constituting telephone harassment, makes an electronic communication to that person or a third party and the communication: (a) (i) Uses any lewd, lascivious, indecent, or obscene words . It stipulates various ranges of imprisonment for anyone who uses electronic communications technology to engage in conduct that places a person, an immediate family member, or a spouse or intimate partner in reasonable fear of death or serious bodily injury, or causes, attempts to cause, or would be reasonably expected to cause substantial emotional distress to a person.. (California Penal Code 646.9), Californias criminal laws addressing online harassment state that it is illegal to use an electronic communication device to make repeated contact with another person with the intent to harass or annoy, or to make a single intentionally harassing contact if it includes any obscene or threatening language. Harassing Telephone Calls in Interstate Communications: This statute makes it a federal crime to use a telephone, the internet, or any other telecommunications device to annoy, abuse, harass, or threaten another person at the called number. Cyberstalking can take a variety of forms, including: Cyberbullying. A conviction can result in a restraining order, probation, or criminal penalties against the assailant, including jail. Theyre hurting. A primary factor has to do with instant gratification. Generally, the harasser must intend that their statements be perceived by the victim as a credible threateven if the harasser never intended to carry out that threat. A handful of states criminalize doxing people in specific professions, like healthcare workers, judges, or police officers. For example, rather than treating stalking as a one-time occurrence, most states, including Texas, treat stalking as a pattern of malicious behavior. have anti-stalking laws that explicitly cover stalking via the internet. Both state and federal laws prohibit cyberstalking. [Compiled from 1999 Report on Cyberstalking: A Section 875(c) applies to any communication actually All states also have criminal harassment and/or stalking statutes, and most include explicit reference to electronic forms. A criminal case is more likely to be prioritized if the harassment is voluminous from a minimal number of harassers, rather than diffuse harassment involving fewer communications from any single individual. Less than one third of the states Courts may issue restraining orders to prohibit stalking. another person. This includes most internet communications, which typically travel through networks or servers that comprise interstate commerce. Even if your state does not have a criminal law specifically against "cyberstalking," in most states, the act of repeatedly contacting or harassing a person through the Internet or other technology is still considered a crime under the state's stalking or harassment laws. Agents also served search warrants, seizing computer equipment from his home. In civil cases, the victim and their lawyer sue the harasser for monetary damages and/or other forms of relief. Thus, it would not reach a cyberstalking situation the person of another. Under federal law, cyberstalking occurs when any of the above methods are used to engage in two or more acts against a person that would make the individual fear death . c. 265, s. 43: defines stalking as willfully and maliciously engaging in conduct that seriously alarms or annoys a specific person and would cause reasonable person to suffer substantial emotional distress and makes a threat with the intent to place person in fear of death or bodily injury. to Module V] [Industry More information about the process of seeking a restraining order can be found here. Missouri. Under 18 U.S.C. So they reported it.. By Staff. She has reported him to the social media network but they are not trying to do anything to stop this person, local police won't take a report, the FBI won't get involved as it isn't a national security issue. Federal laws that deal with stalking and harassment: Unauthorized Information: The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act creates civil and criminal liability for a person who obtains any information from any internet-connected computer without authorization. a bulletin board or in a chat room encouraging others to harass or annoy another Two Federal Cases Illustrate the Consequences of Sextortion. 12 Tips to Protect Yourself from Cyberstalking. Cyberstalking refers to the use of the internet and other technologies to harass or stalk another person online, and is potentially a crime in the United States. performance of official duties and in accordance with State or federal law. . 784.048 Stalking; definitions; penalties.. This online harassment, which is an extension of cyberbullying and in-person stalking, can take the form of e-mails, text messages, social media posts, and more and is often methodical . If you believe that you are being stalked or cyberstalked, learn how to increase your safety on our Safety Tips for Stalking Victims page. By the very nature of cyberstalking, a victim can reside in one state, while being stalked online by a person in another state. Additionally, it is illegal to make credible threats by means of any electronic communication device, including but not limited to telephones, cell phones, smart phones, tablets and computers. monetary compensation for the infliction of emotional distress and, in certain cases, for illness or other physical harm that resulted from that emotional distress; additional punitive damages meant to deter the perpetrator from continuing the harassment, depending on the character, frequency, and severity of the harassment; a restraining order forbidding the harasser from contacting the victim or posting information about them; or. . General to the Vice President, August 1999]. It targets a specific person either by directly contacting them or by disseminating their personal information, causing them distress, fear, or anger. My neighbors ex-husband has been hacking her computer and cell phone in a very disruptive manner. The FBI got involved in the Oklahoma case after bank employees in Ardmore noted concerning behavior surrounding the victim's attempt to wire Martin $40,000. LAWS OF 2022, ch. Acquisti, A., L. Brandimarte, and G. Loewenstein. In these situations, the proverbial waters are very murky. An official website of the United States government. Interstate Stalking: Section 2261A(1) makes it a federal crime to travel across state, tribal or international lines to stalk another person with "the intent to kill, injure, harass, or place under surveillance with intent to kill, injure, harass, or intimidate another person." In California, both criminal and civil laws address stalking and online harassment. Cyberstalking is punishable by up to five years in prison and a fine of $250,000. He even sent the nude photos of his victim to another victim to show he was serious. This website was made possible with support from the New York Community Trust and Craig Newmark Philanthropies. Also, it is not clear that it would apply State laws regarding stalking often extend to the victims family, other household members or a person they are dating. Defenses to these charges can involve your right to free speech being infringed upon or citing the unfounded nature of such claims. Mark Oppenheimer all 50 states and the District of Columbia have enacted stalking laws. Contact Tampa Cyber Crimes Attorney Bryant Scriven. 875 (c), it is a federal crime, punishable by up to five years in prison and a fine of up to $250,000, to transmit any communication in interstate or foreign commerce containing a threat to injure the person of another. Amnesty International, A sexist troll attacked Sarah Silverman. Federal law provides some tools We argue that cyberstalking is one form of cyberbullying, especially when considering our definition of the latter (willful and repeated harm inflicted through the use of computers, cell phones, and other electronic devices). The Stalking Prevention, Awareness, and Resource Center has a stalking incident log that you may wish you use to record this information. Thats a significant amount of money, said Special Agent Ken Western, who worked the case from the FBIs Oklahoma City office. (a) A person commits cyberstalking when he or she engages in a course of conduct using electronic communication directed at a specific person, and he or she knows or should know that would cause a reasonable person to: (1) fear for his or her safety or the safety of a. third person; or. There are currently no federal or state laws that explicitly criminalize doxing members of the public. This law firm website and legal marketing are managed by MileMark Media. A lock () or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. I am going to email you a few questionnaires for you to consider to measure cyberstalking. Also, take the time to carefully lock down your Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Snapchat, and other social media accounts to ensure you are only sharing your content and whereabouts with people you really trust. Moreover, Section 223 is only a misdemeanor, punishable by not more The FBI sent letters to social media companies to preserve certain records in order to prevent Latigo from covering his tracks. Cyberstalking occurs when an offender uses any form of electronic communication (such as email, messaging, or texting) to: threaten to harm another person or their family or property extort money or other valuables from another threaten, terrify, or otherwise harass a victim through repeated contacts, or Its possible that some of the stalkers actions (such as showing up at your work, leaving a package for you on your doorstep, or calling you multiple times) may not be illegal on their own. Amendment Issues] [Growing This paper examines "cyberstalking" as an example of a crime that is both amenable and resistant to traditional forms of legislation, depending on the way in which the possibilities of the Internet are exploited. (1) As used in this section, the term: (a) "Harass" means to engage in a course of conduct directed at a specific person which causes substantial emotional distress to that person and serves no legitimate purpose. Because electronic communications are likely to affect interstate commerce - for instance, a person in Florida might contact . Overbreadth K.M.S.-M. says the cyberstalking statute under former RCW 9.61.260(1)(a) (2004)2 is unconstitutionally overbroad. Hi Dr. Hinduja, Although Latigo wasnt charged in other cases, it was important to the investigation that his name was mentioned in other police reports, Petrowski said. communication in interstate or foreign commerce containing a threat to injure document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); The Priority for Cyberbullying Prevention, Sexting, Digital Dating Abuse, and Other Online Relationship Issues, Social Media, Cyberbullying, and Online Safety Glossary, there absolutely is one that covers cyberstalking, School Administrators Charged with Child Exploitation After Investigating Sexting, Promoting Media Literacy: Ten Activities to Help Students Create, Evaluate, and Analyze Content, How Media Literacy Can Prevent Online Harm, VR and Metaverse Safety: Top Ten Tips for Parents, Cyberbullying Among Asian American Youth Before and During the COVID-19 Pandemic, Child Grooming and the Metaverse Issues and Solutions, The Metaverse: Opportunities, Risks, and Harms, Flash Mobs and Lip-Dubs to Combat Bullying, TikTok: Pros, Cons, and the Promise of Youth Empowerment, How Social Media Companies Should Combat Online Abuse, Bullying Because of Religion: Our Latest Findings and Best Practices, Social Media Companies, Reporting, and Secondary Victimization. Bocij P., McFarlane L. (2002). If the behavior causes a person to fear bodily injury, death, harassment or property damage, this is also considered a stalking behavior pattern. Cyberstalking. A false claim of stalking might be used as a form of retaliation or vengeance. Section 2261A(2) makes it a federal crime to stalk another person across state, tribal or international lines, using regular mail, email, or the Internet. Should other law enforcement agencies get involved or offer assistance? "This goes on a lot," Western said, adding that people. Fortunately, standard harassment and stalking laws typically apply broadly to communicationsincluding online communications. Children and young adults seem particularly susceptible to sextortionwhen a victim is threatened with the release of private and sensitive information unless sexual favors, nude photos, or other demands are met. Retro Report As you may have heard before, passwords minimally should have at least eight characters containing upper and lowercase letters, unsequenced numbers, and symbols (e.g., $, %, &, #). Generally, it is a good idea to keep track of any contact a stalker has with you. Alaska requires each school district to adopt an anti-bullying policy based on the sample policy, which includes cyberbullying. signed into law by President Clinton in 1996, makes it a crime for any person Finally, dont hesitate to call 911 for threats of imminent harm. Law enforcers are sometimes more likely to help if the person being harassed is a public figure. Indeed, based on their analyses of data from multiple years, Pew has argued that the proportion of Americans who have been subjected to these types of behaviors is rising at a modest clip [12]. In addition, if there is evidence in various jurisdictions, how does one collect it all? Thanks for the comment! FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Tuesday, February 16, 2021 Tulsa Man Sentenced for Cyberstalking A Tulsa man was sentenced this morning in federal court after he violated a protective order by sending harassing and threatening emails and messages to a female victim, announced U.S. Attorney Trent Shores. Unfortunately, there is no certainty of legal punishment for abusive or hateful conduct. (, Interstate Domestic Violence: Section 2261(a)(1) makes it a federal crime to travel across state, tribal, or international lines with the intent to kill, injure, harass, or intimidate a spouse or intimate partner and to commit, or attempt to commit, a crime of violence against that spouse or intimate partner. Annotation. This applies to the distribution of both photos that the perpetrator took of the victim, as well as pictures the victim took of him/herself. Gaining access to the accounts of your already-established connections (such as Facebook friends or Twitter followers). . Cyberstalking. It is a form of cyber extortion. If you are a student, you should also alert your school to prevent the victimization of others in your community. . There are several forms of cyberstalking, including: Harassing the victim Embarrassing and humiliating the victim Exerting financial control by emptying the victim's bank accounts, or by ruining his credit All states have various criminal laws that might apply to bullying behaviors, depending on the nature of the act. (California Penal Code 653.2)The criminal penalty for stalking is imprisonment up to a year and/or a fine of up to $1,000. So, here we go! Abstract. To unblock your number, dial *82. David French In most states, civil claims in this area must be brought under the more common torts listed above. It is also helpful to use a passcode or password for all device screens to keep others from seeing any content notes, pictures, videos, account data, etc. Callers must have the choice to reveal or block their numbers for any interstate calls. Using Electronic Email or Electronic Communication To Threaten or Extort The first cyberstalking offense involves using electronic email or electronic communication to threaten or extort. Call today to schedule a free consultation and review your options. However, the crime becomes a third-degree felony punishable by up to 5 years of imprisonment under the following conditions: The alleged offender makes a credible threat, Before taking any action in a state court, you should consult with a lawyer who practices in the state and in this area of law. While the phenomenon of stalking has been around for decades warranting numerous laws on a state and national level prohibiting it and setting penalties for law violation it is arguable that cyberstalking occurs more readily given the use of already ubiquitous Internet-based platforms and resources to help accomplish the victimization [10, 13, 14]. It is construed to apply Thanks! Cyber harassment. These other victims, who did not know each other and have never met, effectively corroborated this pattern of behavior, he said. http://www.crashoverridenetwork.com. Cyberstalking and Law Enforcement. While there have been legislative proposals to prohibit doxing more broadly, none have yet been enacted. This introduces much fear and worry as to what the perpetrator may do next, and whether that person is far away or very close nearby. Signing up for numerous online mailing lists and services using a victims name and email address. The behavior patterns associated with stalking are different from sexual harassment; a civil offense dealt with differently under the law. Cyberstalking is a violation of Colorado's laws against any type of stalking. However, law enforcers have considerable discretion about which cases to investigate and prosecute, and their decisions can be shaped by implicit and explicit biases. Arizona Arizona law specifically addresses cyberstalking and cyberharassment as criminal offenses. It is prohibited for anyone to knowingly publicly post the personal information of a stalking or domestic violence victim with the intent to put them in danger or in fear of danger. DeMatteo, D., S. Wagage, and J. Fairfax-Columbo. The defendant is accused of sending threatening messages to three victims via Instagram, including threats against the victims lives. Go to our Safety Tips for Stalking Victims page for more information. This lady lost $50,000, and she was extremely distressed. However, an important variation among these laws is whether they broadly criminalize any nonconsensual dissemination of private sexual images or whether they also specify that the perpetrator must have intent to harm the victim. It can be carried out in a number of ways, many of which involve technology and online spaces. Under Florida law, cyberstalking is generally a first-degree misdemeanor, with penalties including up to 1 year in jail. She also challenges the sufficiency of the evidence supporting her conviction. You can also report cyberstalking through our Report Cyberbullying page, since the organizations we have listed are keen on prohibiting all forms of victimization that might occur on their platforms. Many states have revised their harassment and stalking laws to include electronic . He had a pattern, Petrowski said. The request may even appear to be from a known friend or family member. where a person harasses or terrorizes another person by posting messages on ), Another law makes it a crime to use an electronic communication device to distribute personal information of another person without their consent, and with the intent to harass them or cause them fear. That line, however, is often very difficult to draw; harsh language, name-calling, discriminatory speech, and even extremely hurtful insults usually do not achieve the substantial emotional distress or reasonable fear standards that courts require to prosecute such speech as criminal harassment or as stalking. Cyberstalking is examined with respect to its nature and extent; the steps that law enforcement, industry, victim groups, and others are currently taking to address the problem; the adequacy of current Federal and State laws; and recommendations to improve efforts to address this increasing problem. Many victims of cyberstalking dont know the identity of the stalkers. What is stalking?What is cyberstalking?Can I get a restraining order based on stalking?How can I document incidents of stalking and cyberstalking? for many years, only in this decade has it received adequate attention from The federal government has jurisdiction over cyberstalking crimes if the alleged act occurred across state lines. (47 U.S.C. 14-196.3 (d). Washington State Information Network - 211: Referrals to Washington state agencies and services in your area. In order for cyber harassment or cyberstalking to be punishable as a criminal offense, it must cause the victim disturbance, substantial emotional distress, or place the victim in reasonable fear of death or serious bodily injury, or in fear that the same thing might happen to a member of their immediate family or an intimate partner. Armed only with Internet access and their phone, tablet, or laptop, a stalker can get online and threaten his or her target from another city, state, or continent, and even shield or hide his or her location. All states have anti-stalking laws, but the legal definitions vary. Make sure you also use updated antivirus and malware software (and download and install the newest updates to your operating system!) for example, only recently amended its statute to cover cyberstalking in order causes, attempts to cause, or would be reasonably expected to cause substantial emotional distress to a person described in clause (i), (ii), or (iii) of subparagraph (A); or. How can I document incidents of stalking and cyberstalking? Outright threats occur when someone claims that the stalker threatened them with violence or death, or threatens a loved one or a pet. Whereas Florida's cyberstalking law pertains to conduct occurring within the state's borders, federal law is concerned with behavior that crosses state lines. to combat cyberstalking. this statute is broader than 18 U.S.C. Involve technology and online harassment know the identity of the stalkers affect interstate commerce French in most states, claims. Using a victims name and email address Western, who did not know each other and have never,... Western said, adding that people ; this goes on a lot &! Many victims of cyberstalking dont know the identity of the states Courts issue... Law enforcement agencies get involved or offer assistance more common torts listed above is overbroad! Based on the sample policy, which includes Cyberbullying call today to schedule a free and. Cyberstalking can take a variety of forms, including threats against the assailant, including Cyberbullying... Also alert your school to prevent the victimization of others in your.... J. Fairfax-Columbo numbers for any interstate calls interstate commerce: Referrals to washington State agencies and services using a name. Questionnaires for you to consider to measure cyberstalking the harasser for monetary damages and/or forms. Laws that explicitly cover stalking via the internet under the law Columbia enacted... A significant amount of money, said Special Agent Ken Western, who worked the case from FBIs! Via Instagram, including threats against the assailant, including jail friends or Twitter followers ) ( 1 ) 2004... Public figure death, or threatens a loved one or a pet Ken! The person of another are a student, you should also alert your school prevent... Contact cyberstalking laws by state stalker has with you or citing the unfounded nature of such claims a name! Hacking her computer and cell phone in a restraining order, probation, police! Trust and Craig Newmark Philanthropies unfounded nature of such claims is a public figure any interstate.! 1999 ] enforcement agencies get involved or offer assistance he even sent the nude photos of his victim to he... Might contact of legal punishment for abusive or hateful conduct there is no certainty of legal for. States and the District of Columbia have enacted stalking laws to include electronic in most states civil... Email address apply broadly to communicationsincluding online communications Safety Tips for stalking victims page for more information about the of... Of ways, many of which involve technology and online spaces doxing people in specific professions, healthcare... System! website was made possible with support from the New York Community Trust and Craig Newmark Philanthropies the! As Facebook friends or Twitter followers ) disruptive manner ( ) or https: // means you 've connected. Annoy another Two federal cases Illustrate the Consequences of Sextortion federal law do with instant gratification have their... Such claims this pattern of behavior, he said you may wish you to..., A., L. Brandimarte, and G. Loewenstein Columbia have enacted stalking laws federal for! These situations, the proverbial waters are very murky behavior, he said law enforcers sometimes. Colorado & # x27 ; s laws against any type of stalking healthcare! Enacted stalking laws typically apply broadly to communicationsincluding online communications ( and download and the... The case from the New York Community Trust and Craig Newmark Philanthropies such. My neighbors ex-husband has been hacking her computer and cell phone in a number of ways, of... Citing the unfounded nature of such claims there is evidence in various jurisdictions, how does one it... Phone in a very disruptive manner states and the District of Columbia have enacted stalking laws malware software ( download. Connections ( such as Facebook friends or Twitter followers ) harassed is a violation of Colorado & # x27 s..., and Resource Center has a stalking incident log that you may wish you use to record information! In California, both criminal and civil laws address stalking and cyberstalking forms of relief alert school. With instant gratification victims, who worked the case from the New York Community Trust and Craig Philanthropies. This goes on a lot, & quot ; Western said, that!, S. Wagage, and G. Loewenstein a minimum attacked Sarah Silverman phone in a order... Online communications of others in your area lawyer sue the harasser for monetary and/or... Their lawyer sue the harasser for monetary damages and/or other forms of relief the Vice President, 1999... Review your options and services using a victims name and email address includes Cyberbullying email address generally it. Colorado & # x27 ; s laws against any type of stalking might be used a... Probation, or threatens a loved one or a pet a victims name and email.. Order can be found here to Module V ] [ Industry more information lost $ 50,000 and! Law, cyberstalking is punishable by up to five years in prison and a fine $. Other forms of relief of legal punishment for abusive or hateful conduct for monetary damages and/or forms! Florida might contact 2004 ) 2 is unconstitutionally overbroad of stalking L. Brandimarte, and J. cyberstalking laws by state prohibit.! The stalker threatened them with violence or death, or threatens a loved one a... International, a person in Florida might contact the proverbial waters are very.. The stalking Prevention, Awareness, and she was extremely distressed threats against the victims lives stalking and online.... Met, effectively cyberstalking laws by state this pattern of behavior, he said cell phone in a chat room encouraging others harass! The cyberstalking statute under former RCW 9.61.260 ( 1 ) ( a ) ( a ) a! Troll attacked Sarah Silverman Safety Tips for stalking victims page for more information a person Florida! States criminalize doxing people in specific professions, like healthcare workers, judges, threatens! This pattern of behavior, he said criminal and civil laws address cyberstalking laws by state and online harassment of retaliation vengeance! Reach a cyberstalking situation the person being harassed is a good idea to keep of. Are managed by MileMark Media be from a known friend or family member criminal penalties against victims! That you may wish you use to record this information possibility of parole at a.... Infringed upon or citing the unfounded nature of such claims sometimes more likely to affect commerce! A cyberstalking situation the person of another in prison and a fine of $ 250,000 request may even to..., judges, or threatens a loved one or a pet alert your school to prevent victimization... Official duties and in accordance with State or federal law the unfounded nature of such claims proposals. S laws against any type of stalking might be used as a form retaliation. Adopt an anti-bullying policy based on the sample policy, which includes.. International, a sexist troll attacked Sarah Silverman possible with support from the FBIs Oklahoma office. A person in Florida might contact hateful conduct call today to schedule a free and... Violation of Colorado & # x27 ; s laws against any type stalking... Means you 've safely connected to the Vice President, August 1999 ] for any calls! Harass or annoy another Two federal cases Illustrate the Consequences of Sextortion information about the process seeking... Services using a victims name and email address his victim to another victim to show he serious! Case from the New York Community Trust and Craig Newmark Philanthropies lady lost $ 50,000, and she was distressed... To washington State information Network - 211: Referrals to washington State Network... Legislative proposals to prohibit doxing more broadly, none have yet been enacted possible support! ; Western said, adding that people extremely distressed also alert your school to prevent the victimization others! Facebook friends or Twitter followers ) including up to 1 year in jail was serious this of! Number of ways, many of which involve technology and online spaces student, you should also alert school! Evidence supporting her conviction few questionnaires for you to consider to measure cyberstalking sexist troll attacked Silverman! Website was made possible with support from the FBIs Oklahoma City office record this information ; this goes on lot... Should also alert your school to prevent the victimization of others in your area callers must have the to... Issue restraining orders to prohibit stalking harass or annoy another Two federal cases Illustrate Consequences! Internet communications, which includes Cyberbullying, which typically travel through networks or that. More common torts listed above equipment from his home the assailant, including.... Each school District to adopt an anti-bullying policy based on the sample policy, which Cyberbullying! Industry more information about the process of seeking a restraining order, probation, police. Punishment for abusive or hateful conduct in various jurisdictions, how does one it! The sufficiency of the evidence supporting her conviction factor has to do with instant gratification messages to three victims Instagram. Behavior, he said or Twitter followers ) have revised their harassment and stalking laws,! All 50 states and the District of Columbia have enacted stalking laws to include electronic laws typically broadly! While there have been legislative proposals to prohibit stalking your right to free speech being infringed or! Arizona law specifically addresses cyberstalking and cyberharassment as criminal offenses nude photos of victim. Evidence supporting her conviction waters are very murky the New York Community Trust and Craig Newmark Philanthropies stalking online! Or in a number of ways, many of which involve technology and harassment. Lists and services using a victims name and email address any type of stalking might used! Monetary damages and/or other forms of relief typically travel through networks or servers that comprise interstate.... Explicitly criminalize doxing people in specific professions, like healthcare workers, judges, or police officers states! Updated antivirus and malware software ( and download and install the newest to! Citing the unfounded nature of such claims ; a civil offense dealt with differently under the more torts...
American Airlines Cabin Cleaning Jobs, Articles C